
On November 16, 2026, Senators Patty Murray of Washington, Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire and Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin asked HHS Inspector General T. March Bell to investigate how staffing and policy changes at FDA and CDC affected the federal response to this summer’s Cyclospora outbreak. Their letter ends with thirteen questions.
The Inspector General should open that investigation. The questions are the right ones, most of them can be answered from records the agencies already hold, and nobody with authority to pull those records has yet done it. In the interest of disclosure: my firm represents people sickened in this outbreak.
Why an independent review is warranted
The outbreak that CDC and FDA tied to shredded iceberg lettuce from Taylor Farms de Mexico closed at 12,883 illnesses, 570 hospitalizations and two deaths in 21 states. CDC declared it over on September 11. FDA closed its investigation on October 2 after finding the parasite in a tank of outgoing wastewater at the processing plant and in a drainage ditch at a grower in its traceback. FDA could not say how the parasite got onto the lettuce.
It is the largest Cyclospora outbreak recorded in the United States. An event of that size calls for an after-action review by an office that can read internal email, pull inspection assignments and interview staff. No such review has been made public.
What the letter gets right
The inspection gap. The Associated Press reported that FDA inspectors reached the Taylor Farms site in Guanajuato in mid-August, about a month after the July 17 recall, and that it was the agency’s first visit there in more than seven years. The senators ask why it took a month and why the facility had gone uninspected since 2019. Both answers are sitting in FDA’s files.
The people behind the inspectors. The letter says the administration removed the support staff who arranged inspectors’ travel, scheduling and paperwork, and it cites FDA’s own data dashboard for the point that 2025 had the lowest inspection count since 2011 outside the pandemic years. In January 2025 the Government Accountability Office made three recommendations on retaining food investigators. The letter says FDA agreed with them and, as of June 2026, had not acted on key parts. An inspector general can confirm or correct each of those statements quickly.
The laboratory and the surveillance network. The letter says the CDC laboratory that responds to Cyclosporaoutbreaks went from eleven people to three last year. Separately, in July 2025 HHS cut FoodNet’s required surveillance list from eight pathogens to two, which made active Cyclospora surveillance optional. HHS has defended that change as removing duplicate work and has said tracking continued through other systems. Secretary Kennedy has called criticism of the response invalid. Those are testable claims, and testing them is what the Inspector General’s office is for.
The influence question. The letter says Taylor Farms “reportedly” met with the White House and made political contributions to change the course of the investigation. What is on the public record is narrower than that. The Wall Street Journal reported that the company called the White House to try to delay the recall. Federal Election Commission records, as ABC News reported, show a $1 million donation from Taylor Fresh Foods to MAGA Inc. in March 2025. The company told ABC that it acts on science and consumer health, “not politics.” That is a news report, a public filing and a denial. Whether any of it moved the date of a recall or an inspection is unknown. I do not assume the answer. I want someone with access to the call logs and email to find it.
Where I would widen the lens
The decline did not start in January 2025. The same AP reporting found FDA’s foreign food inspections down nearly 35 percent since 2019, that the agency was missing its congressionally mandated foreign inspection targets before the pandemic, and that former regulators say Congress never funded those targets. A credible review should cover the whole decade and both branches. That cuts in a useful direction: all three signers sit on the Appropriations Committee, and the remedy for an underfunded inspectorate is written there.
The cases with no food named. As of its September 15 update, CDC’s national case data showed 19,883 laboratory-confirmed domestic cases for the May 1 to August 31 season. The lettuce outbreak accounts for 12,883. That leaves 7,000 confirmed illnesses with no food identified. The letter does not ask about them. The Inspector General should ask what CDC and FDA did to find those sources and whether they had the staff to try.
Traceability. The letter’s seventh question notes that FDA’s Food Traceability Rule now takes effect in July 2028. Its original compliance date was January 2026. A traceback that runs through a processor to several farms in another country is the case the rule was written for. The review should say plainly what the delay cost in this investigation, and Congress should not extend the date again.
Hold hearings, and invite the public
Mr. Bell was confirmed on December 18, 2025, and leads an office of about 1,370 auditors, evaluators and investigators. A request from three senators in the minority does not obligate him to act. When FDA closed its investigation on October 2, I counted fifteen congressional letters about this outbreak with no published answer.
An inspector general’s review, if it comes, will take months and happen behind closed doors. Congress should not wait for it. The committees with jurisdiction over FDA and CDC in both chambers should hold hearings this winter, and the chairs, who hold the gavel and the subpoena, should call them. Food safety has not been a partisan subject for most of my career. The Food Safety Modernization Act passed in 2010 with votes from both parties.
The public belongs in the room. Put the people who were sick at the witness table next to the agency heads, along with state epidemiologists, growers and the company. Hold at least one field hearing in Michigan, where both of the people who died lived. Stream every session and open a record for written statements from anyone who was ill or lost income. I will testify if asked, and I will bring clients who are willing.
What we need to do in the short run: before May 1, 2027
The next Cyclospora season, as CDC defines it, opens May 1. Before then:
Inspector General Bell should open the review and publish its scope and a completion date.
FDA and CDC should answer the thirteen questions in public. None requires an investigation to answer.
HHS should put Cyclospora back on FoodNet’s required list and restaff the CDC parasitology laboratory.
FDA should restore the support staff its inspectors lost and inspect the Mexican iceberg operations that ship here before the season starts.
CDC and FDA should report what they have done to find the source of the 7,000 unexplained cases.
Taylor Farms should publish the independent third-party review that its own information page says its decisions will rest on.
What we need to do in the long run
Set and fund inspection targets for foreign food facilities comparable to the domestic ones, which is the letter’s eighth question.
Hold the traceability date at July 2028 and stop moving it.
Carry out the GAO’s recommendations so that FDA keeps the inspectors it trains.
Fund FDA, CDC and state health department surveillance at the level the job requires, year after year, so that the next response does not depend on who was laid off the year before.
Bring retail produce sampling back, as USDA’s Microbiological Data Program once did, so that contamination is found before thousands of people are sick.
I have been asking the leafy greens industry and its regulators to put me out of the lettuce business. Thirteen answered questions and a public hearing would be a start.













