Two Sentenced to Death in Melamine Milk Scandal in China - What United States Food Company Executives are Thinking?

Reuters reported yesterday that a Chinese court sentenced two men to death for their role in the production and sale of melamine-tainted milk that killed at least six children and made nearly 300,000 ill.   The former head of the dairy firm at the heart of the scandal, the now bankrupt Sanlu Group, got life in prison and a fine.  I was stunned, but not surprised at the anger directed at the executive of Sanlu:

"I think she should be shot. A death for a death," said Zheng Shuzhen, a 48-year-old grandmother from central Henan province, who said her one-year-old granddaughter, Zhou Mengxian, died in June of kidney failure after drinking Sanlu milk formula but was not included in the list of victims.

Six died in China last year over melamine-tainted milk and six have died in the last months in the United States over Salmonells-tainted peanut butter.  Five died in 2006 due to E. coli-tainted spinach and 5,000 die each year in the United States due too food poisoning.  The CDC also estimates that another 325,000 are hospitalized and 76 Million are sickened each year in the United States by food.  Does anyone recall a criminal prosecution?  One must wonder what United States food company executives are thinking?  Perhaps pleased that their parents did not choose to live in China?

Interestingly, AP reported just a few days ago, "China families take milk case to highest court." More than 200 families whose babies fell ill after drinking tainted infant formula are taking their case to China's highest court after being repeatedly ignored by lower courts.  One wonders, if Chinese citizens had the same rights that we take for granted, that death sentences would be fewer and farther between.  Here is a quote from on of the plaintiffs:

"The reason why I'm bringing this case to court is not about money but about my child's future," said Zhang Ge, a single mother in Beijing who quit her job at an Internet advertising company to look after her sick son.

When Will China Ban US Peanut Butter?

I am just waiting for the gleeful press release from China - "China Says Nope to US Peanut Butter."

I can hear the howling of US interests who abhor imports of all kinds - people, food (poisoned or not) - Lou Dobbs, are you listening?  Hey, not to say that China's food production safety record is anything to cheer about, but over the years US food production has done a wonderful job of poisoning US citizens.  Thanks to Consumerist for Photo.

I can not get to China too soon - Chinese milk powder contaminated with melamine sickens 1,253 babies

Sanlu, China’s biggest milk powder manufacturer, sold contaminated milk after farmers laced their produce with industrial chemicals to increase its protein content.  Chinese hospitals are fighting to save the lives of some of the 1,253 babies who have fallen sick after they were fed milk powder contaminated with an industrial chemical used to make plastic cups and saucers.  Two babies have already died from drinking the formula laced with melamine in a ploy by farmers to boost the apparent protein content of the milk that they sold to one of the best-known milk powder manufacturers in the country. Police have arrested nineteen people, including two brothers who ran a milk collection station.  And, I still have not finished packing.

According to press reports:

The children are victims of two of China’s greatest evils: greed and secrecy. Greed has contributed to poor safety: only a few years ago 13 babies died after they were fed a sub-stand-ard fake formula marketed under the Sanlu brand. The determination to stage a perfect Olympic Games may also have delayed revelation of the adulterated milk powder. Twenty-one topics were banned from Chinese media during the Olympics – eighth on the list was food safety scandals.

I do not give my talk in China until next week, but I thought I would put it up here now so my friends in China can get a early preview:

 

China Milk Farmers Blamed in Baby Formula Contamination

Well, I'm off to China this week and it appears that it is not a moment too soon.

The Chinese firm whose baby formula is blamed for killing one infant and sickening dozens has accused dairy suppliers of adding a chemical to their milk to up protein content, state media said this morning.  Chinese authorities announced a nationwide probe today into the Sanlu Group's milk powder as babies fell seriously ill with kidney stones across the country, in the latest scandal to rock China's food industry.  One child has died.

Xinhua news agency said police in Shijiazhuang had arrested 78 "suspects" in the case, but gave no further information.  China's health ministry today ordered all its departments nationwide to immediately report every baby with kidney stones and difficulty urinating, symptoms of drinking the tainted milk formula.

China International Food Safety & Quality Conference + Expo in 2008.

I am off to China to the International Food Safety & Quality Conference and Expo in a few weeks.  I am proud to be the lead sponsor of the event and am glad that I was able to convince our former Governor, Gary Locke, to attend as well.  China will become over the coming decades an even greater trading partner in food.  Coming up with strategies to help create an environment and culture where safe food is important is important to me.


Food safety is a worldwide issue that can benefit greatly from collaboration, standardized approaches, and common solutions. In many countries, food safety awareness is at an all-time high. New and emerging threats to the food supply are constantly being discovered, and our food supply is becoming increasingly global. Achieving food safety success in this changing environment requires novel prevention strategies, greater harmonization and more collaboration at the international level than ever before. As a responsible partner in the international food safety community, the General Administration for Quality Supervision Inspection & Quarantine (AQSIQ) is once again hosting the China International Food Safety & Quality Conference + Expo in 2008.